Showing posts with label justifications. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justifications. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 29, 2015

Cycle of Cruelty

Following their first act of cruelty came others to keep them dominant over those they had injured, fearful always of retaliation. Over time there were only more and more cruel acts, more people injured and so more vengeance to fear. They needed with each act to feel increased justification for what they had done, and their fear turned injured people to a thread against which they must be vigilant and pre-emptive in their attacks. They blamed victims for being angry, pressing the repression more tightly, and so compressing and solidifying the rage. Where retaliation did seep out it seemed a massive dose of new cruelty was the only remedy considered, and so the cycle spun faster with less likelihood it could be controlled.

Thursday, March 5, 2015

Explaining Why

We seem better able to say what we might do, which is the practical aspect of therapy, than why we would, which is the philosophical and more essential component.

Friday, October 24, 2014

First Change

First change.  If you still need an explanation, you can look for it later.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Justifying the Doctor

Going to the doctor there is concern we will not be sick enough to justify the trip.  The time and expense involved make it important that there be "something" though we can hope it will not be terrible.  The worst we could hear is that nothing is wrong.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Opposites

Only in physics (or is it chemistry) do opposites attract.  In other instances they have to look for each other, then justify having found one another if their opposition will not be reconciled.

Monday, February 17, 2014

Underselling Catholic School Week

It was Catholic School Week and so it was the featured player at the liturgy.  It seemed hard for the speaker to find a way to claim to be better -- rather than as good as -- the public school.  It seemed like trying to justify one's being without offending others.  The problem is in justifying, which grows out of comparison.  The school needed to sell itself as school, as religious school; and there it began to stumble over clichés, bumping into amorphous sayings, and back-pedaling from anything people might be reluctant to hear.  Crashing on through phrases well worn by time and use, the speaker tried to say nothing while sounding like she had just what someone might want.  Having spent a suitable amount of time at it she gratefully sat down, no more grateful than were her hearers who -- too polite (or deadened) to scratch their heads and well past the point of yawning -- stood to mumble their belief.

Monday, October 7, 2013

Rising Above Nationhood

Nations are not unlike individuals.  The terrorized become terrorists.  The powerless seizing control become as ruthless in their wielding of it.  But neither individuals nor nations have a right to the justifications they offer.  Knowing the cause does not permit our continuing what went wrong.  We can appreciate what it has meant and how the rage developed but containing, stopping, and moving beyond violence are of greater value and provide dignity to who we will become, in spite of what happened before.

Friday, October 4, 2013

Argument Regret

The conversation, if that is what we would call it, lasted no more than a minute or two but in that time I was offered five arguments if I was willing to have them.  None was over anything significant.  We might have pretended we were engaged in essential points of discussion, exchanged some guilt, talked more loudly than was necessary and for a moment felt more justified than there was reason to.  Better to have declined.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Prayer Is Not For Asking

If the answer is that it will be according to his will, then why ask.  Why provide input that will not be an influence in the making of decisions.  When the need is real and the request hardly outrageous, when the asking is sincere, it is still all right that there be an answer of no.  This, however, is a response we could hope would justify itself, if it would.  But there is no justifying, no clarification.  Better perhaps that prayer be an expression of acceptance, a ceding of control and declining to wish to understand.  Better to do away with the asking if it is such an unnecessary step.

Monday, May 6, 2013

Being Annoyed By The Apostles

The boys were annoyed by the story of Ananias and Sapphira, thinking the disciples unfair and more demanding than was right.  It bothered them too that the disciples would be so deceptive, trying to trick Sapphira when they already knew the facts.  Had I wanted to justify the disciples -- and initially I thought I might try -- there was no way they would be willing to think these deaths made sense.  They had decided -- I am pleased to say -- that no matter who you might be or whatever your reason, you do not let people be hurt; and you certainly take no part in the hurting of them.

The apostles might have gotten carried away with their importance or forgotten the example they were to have followed.  Maybe they were thinking things more important than people or had decided that forgiveness had less of a role than it ought.  Whatever the reason, annoyance was the more correct response, as was the realization that even apostles lose sight of what ought to be.

Monday, December 17, 2012

Justifying Life's Rules

If we have no rules, life becomes chaotic.  Having too many, or having ones providing too great a penalty, is to be constricted.  Not having certainty that there are rules at all, or concern they might change, makes life too tentative.  There need to be rules, but they need to justify themselves so there will be less likelihood of their changing.  A proposition may become a rule if it is universal, or almost so -- if it always applies; if it provides a basis for prediction; if it is the same across conditions; and if it applies to most people or most can agree on its reasonableness.

Sunday, November 18, 2012

Needing to Be Complete

Both were accurate.  The pharisee was better than most.  The publican had sinned.  What robbed the pharisee of justification was his need to compare himself with others.  He was that insecure.  He could not consider himself complete within himself, and so needed to lean on the weakness of others.

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Taking Up Causes

Bleeding for causes does not make them right.  Nor need it even mean you believe in them.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Justifying Justifications

Any number of things can be justified.  The question is whether they should be.