My father was a writer. He wrote all of his life, inflicting upon many of us his novels, plays, articles, essays, and self-help books. Some were marvelous; some merely well-intentioned. But of all the things he wrote, his journal is his legacy: by turns wise and bewildering, it neared 1,100 type-written pages when he died in 2010. Although perused many times, this is the first time it will be read - cover to cover, page after page.
Showing posts with label misunderstanding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label misunderstanding. Show all posts
Monday, August 3, 2015
Seeing Bartimaeus
In the story of Bartimaeus, the bishop had thought Jesus' friends had not understood and so they tried to protect him from this shouting blind man. This Sunday, the priest thought it more central to see them leading the blind man forward. They were his advocates. Actually, they had done both. Followers do not always understand, but sometimes they do. We get in the way, but sometimes we do not stay there.
Saturday, August 1, 2015
The Sadness
People who would overlook or diminish the sadness have not understood, and if they would say the past is over they have not seen it alive in our hearts. We are the sadness and sometimes we are it more than anything else. The past, at least on some days, is more vital than the moment. They seem to be what anchor us. It is not that all that is good and valued is over, or that happiness is not allowed to be real. Rather it is that we have a part of our being in events that form us, and when time has covered them over the present times will not be any more over than in the history we already carry. It means too that at the center of the core there is emptiness that rises up. In the terrible sadness we can find more real than what surrounds it on other days, but there are those days, and there are times when the sadness does seem over. There is happiness, too, and it is in its moments as real as anything else, but it seems more fleeting and less able to compete.
Sunday, June 21, 2015
Mistaking God Again
He seemed to suggest our relationship to God is not unlike that of the tenant farmer to the owner of the land. While we are given use of the world, it has to be at a substantial cost. I assume it is a notion deriving from a time when peasants farmed the lord's estate in a system that gave them more obligations than rights and only an appearance of freedom. What is not given -- be it life or use of land -- impinges on freedom, since the contract is subjected constantly to revocation or to the imposing of conditions. This is another failure to understand God and belies our inability to see him as he is rather than as we would make him. God does not lend. He instead gives and when he does he does not take back. God the landlord and God, lord of the manner, are our mistake, not his reality.
Saturday, June 13, 2015
Misunderstood God
It would be a silly God who had not understood people would make mistakes. It would be a one-sided (or lop-sided) God who focused only on those mistakes. It would be a terribly insecure and angry God who required retribution. So, we have probably misunderstood.
Labels:
anxiety,
fear,
focus,
foolishness,
God,
insecurity,
mistakes,
misunderstanding
Thursday, April 2, 2015
Misunderstanding
The young man asked and Jesus responded, and because he did and because the man wanted to hear even more, Jesus may have thought he was also agreeing. Perhaps he did, but in the end the man went away. Maybe his understanding had been only of the words. Maybe the young man's sadness was as great as Jesus' own at what might have been, but in that moment could not be.
Saturday, August 30, 2014
After Addiction
Having moved beyond the addictive part of their addiction people are finding themselves with religious experiences marked by submission and fear, experiences and punitive as they had been years ago. It was a God who might give but who as readily might take away, and in as capricious a way. Sadly, they were calling this spirituality.
Friday, August 1, 2014
Partial Truth
As long as there is only one correct response, one right way to be, a single proper way to act we will run after it, letting go whatever seemed only partially true, not realizing that partially true things are as true as anything else we might run in pursuit of.
Monday, July 14, 2014
Opinions vs. Advice
When you ask some people what they think, they answer with what you should do. They have either misunderstood the question or their role.
Sunday, March 2, 2014
Teaching And Learning
If you came only to teach, not realizing also and more so your need to learn, you have misunderstood what was expected.
Friday, February 14, 2014
Misunderstanding
There are a lot of people saying "have to" when that is not what they have to mean.
Saturday, May 4, 2013
Freedom Within You
If you are asking for your freedom, you have not understood that it is within you. It was to be acknowledged rather than sought.
Friday, February 1, 2013
A Change for the Church
Over time Churches have looked upon themselves as teachers of righteousness, the guardians of what is right and holy. They have trouble understanding how anyone might want to define them differently, why they are assigned a different role or why there is a different connotation to the role and equating of them with what is least in any established institution.
No one would deny Churches have done and continue to undertake a great deal of good. They have provided extensive service and they have tried to be faithful to the Gospel as they have understood it. But some of what is best tends to be seen as over rather than as vital as we may wish. In part this is because others have taken over some of the roles. State and other charitable groups are offering at least as much and sometimes may do it better, and it has not always been possible for Churches to decide what they will now do instead. Unless there can be a new function there may be an enshrining of what was, a moving into what used to be, a place they do not really belong.
It is only true that Churches have become aspects of established society. It is, and should be, part of the fabric of the society of which religion is an aspect. It is what it wanted to become. There was a time, at least in this country, where Churches felt a need to be accepted or recognized, when they felt it was their role to be part of the whole. That was, and remains, a reasonable goal and in some ways it has been accomplished. The goal has been met.
But religion is then made focus of the criticism leveled against society. When people are critical of society, indicating its limitations, accusing it of being too staid, comfortable and maybe stagnant, the Churches are covered by the indictment. When people say the American dream may not have been fulfilled for everyone, or that is was not really as honest, good or holy as it claimed, Churches have an opportunity to consider the truth this may contain and then respond. When people shift their gaze from past horizons to something in the future they may exclude what has been, including the Churches, and if this seems unfair then perhaps religion needs to again justify its inclusion in this new perspective.
Some of what is proposed is revolutionary in tone and in its zeal can be destructive in its formulation. In talking of a new order, there is a facile proposition of destruction and rejection, a making of ashes from which something new can arise. It is more important for some that there be ashes, that the false or unfaithful can be done away with. It is not a helpful formulation, at best a partial truth and only half a goal (if that), but it is an aspect of the fervor and is directed against institutional anything, and Church should not need to be excluded.
The responses of Churchmen have varied. Some assume hate born of disillusion will just disappear. They think if ignored long enough and if their wish is sincere it will just stop. Others recognize and accept the presence of bitterness and frustration, but think themselves virtuous enough and so not needing to reply. In their estimation others may be distressed and we might wish they were not but it would not help them, and would do us less good, were we to change. Others still have said yes to the revolutionary spirit, and have repudiated all they have been a part of. It is as though they were waiting for anything to hang on to, anything that would snatch them beyond what they are an integral part of, so they now dangle within and without. For most, however, response has been in lamenting a lack of understanding, a sad wondering why we were not recognized for who we wished we were.
What do we do? What choices are available? We could be condescending and remain as aloof as we can. We could go along with what we do not, and maybe cannot, comprehend, pretending it made more sense than it does. We could say that what was once so right has become at least as wrong, that we are sorry for whatever we have done or may be doing, that it was all a mistake. Those are choices, though not such good ones. Each Church's answer, and each believer's, will vary and in the end may be as complex and incomplete as was the question.
Part of the response may be realization that Churches do not do well if they settle too readily. It may prosper but cannot flourish if it does not grow and change, questioning itself as well as its setting. It is less itself the more static it becomes, and that is a hard temptation to decline. It is easy and easily justified, but it is a settling in which satisfaction can seem like an accomplishment. If it becomes complacent, religion tends to horde its truths and becomes more defensive than dynamic.
Times and needs change even though God may remain the same. Responses should change as understanding changes, and as there is awareness of what is asked. At most times, Churches have available their role as mediator or reconciler. Mediation is not attempting to incorporate the present into the past, or that reconciliation is between the forces or revolution and those of established tradition. The role is rather to mediate the word of God to the ever-changing world of today, and the today that will be tomorrow, while reconciling the world with God, who can change and grow and share through the process.
Mediation is less easily done by a Church standing on the outside of events, an observer believing itself untouched by time or untouchable by the men and women with whom it shares this world. Any time the assumption is that we have arrived, that change is over, or that this point is the place of arrival rather than one of departure, Church will, like any of us, begin to settle and justification can become more essential than any form of reconciliation. Despite (or maybe because of) origins in God, Churches are temporal and spatial. They live and act in and for a world changing and different and demanding from day to day, and sometimes hour to hour. There is no single answer to today's demands, and perhaps anyone offering a single, all-encompassing response has not understood the question.
No one would deny Churches have done and continue to undertake a great deal of good. They have provided extensive service and they have tried to be faithful to the Gospel as they have understood it. But some of what is best tends to be seen as over rather than as vital as we may wish. In part this is because others have taken over some of the roles. State and other charitable groups are offering at least as much and sometimes may do it better, and it has not always been possible for Churches to decide what they will now do instead. Unless there can be a new function there may be an enshrining of what was, a moving into what used to be, a place they do not really belong.
It is only true that Churches have become aspects of established society. It is, and should be, part of the fabric of the society of which religion is an aspect. It is what it wanted to become. There was a time, at least in this country, where Churches felt a need to be accepted or recognized, when they felt it was their role to be part of the whole. That was, and remains, a reasonable goal and in some ways it has been accomplished. The goal has been met.
But religion is then made focus of the criticism leveled against society. When people are critical of society, indicating its limitations, accusing it of being too staid, comfortable and maybe stagnant, the Churches are covered by the indictment. When people say the American dream may not have been fulfilled for everyone, or that is was not really as honest, good or holy as it claimed, Churches have an opportunity to consider the truth this may contain and then respond. When people shift their gaze from past horizons to something in the future they may exclude what has been, including the Churches, and if this seems unfair then perhaps religion needs to again justify its inclusion in this new perspective.
Some of what is proposed is revolutionary in tone and in its zeal can be destructive in its formulation. In talking of a new order, there is a facile proposition of destruction and rejection, a making of ashes from which something new can arise. It is more important for some that there be ashes, that the false or unfaithful can be done away with. It is not a helpful formulation, at best a partial truth and only half a goal (if that), but it is an aspect of the fervor and is directed against institutional anything, and Church should not need to be excluded.
The responses of Churchmen have varied. Some assume hate born of disillusion will just disappear. They think if ignored long enough and if their wish is sincere it will just stop. Others recognize and accept the presence of bitterness and frustration, but think themselves virtuous enough and so not needing to reply. In their estimation others may be distressed and we might wish they were not but it would not help them, and would do us less good, were we to change. Others still have said yes to the revolutionary spirit, and have repudiated all they have been a part of. It is as though they were waiting for anything to hang on to, anything that would snatch them beyond what they are an integral part of, so they now dangle within and without. For most, however, response has been in lamenting a lack of understanding, a sad wondering why we were not recognized for who we wished we were.
What do we do? What choices are available? We could be condescending and remain as aloof as we can. We could go along with what we do not, and maybe cannot, comprehend, pretending it made more sense than it does. We could say that what was once so right has become at least as wrong, that we are sorry for whatever we have done or may be doing, that it was all a mistake. Those are choices, though not such good ones. Each Church's answer, and each believer's, will vary and in the end may be as complex and incomplete as was the question.
Part of the response may be realization that Churches do not do well if they settle too readily. It may prosper but cannot flourish if it does not grow and change, questioning itself as well as its setting. It is less itself the more static it becomes, and that is a hard temptation to decline. It is easy and easily justified, but it is a settling in which satisfaction can seem like an accomplishment. If it becomes complacent, religion tends to horde its truths and becomes more defensive than dynamic.
Times and needs change even though God may remain the same. Responses should change as understanding changes, and as there is awareness of what is asked. At most times, Churches have available their role as mediator or reconciler. Mediation is not attempting to incorporate the present into the past, or that reconciliation is between the forces or revolution and those of established tradition. The role is rather to mediate the word of God to the ever-changing world of today, and the today that will be tomorrow, while reconciling the world with God, who can change and grow and share through the process.
Mediation is less easily done by a Church standing on the outside of events, an observer believing itself untouched by time or untouchable by the men and women with whom it shares this world. Any time the assumption is that we have arrived, that change is over, or that this point is the place of arrival rather than one of departure, Church will, like any of us, begin to settle and justification can become more essential than any form of reconciliation. Despite (or maybe because of) origins in God, Churches are temporal and spatial. They live and act in and for a world changing and different and demanding from day to day, and sometimes hour to hour. There is no single answer to today's demands, and perhaps anyone offering a single, all-encompassing response has not understood the question.
Tuesday, November 20, 2012
Digging Through Old Arguments
They revisit old arguments, rehashing and digging through them as though somewhere amid the resentment and misunderstanding there was something worth finding. They are like people routing for buried treasure at the dump. It is unlikely anything is there, but if it is, is it worth the effort required and all that must be dug through before finding it?
Thursday, November 15, 2012
The New Normal
They are reporting such craziness as though it made perfect sense. The outrageous has become for them the norm and reality seems so alien, so unwelcoming of them.
Monday, August 20, 2012
Confusing Constructive and Criticism
They seemed to feel that the more devastating their constructive criticism, the greater its value to the target. For their gift they awaited the thanks of someone they had hurt.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)